Thrasymachus on the contrary states that the man who makes a mistake while ruling cannot be termed as a ruler. I order to prove this point Thrasymachus introduces the analogy of craftsman. B introducing the analogy of the craftsman Thrasymachus is thus able to avoid the trap that was set by Socrates by introducing the analogy of the craftsman. Trasymachus highlighted that justice is closely knitted with power. Tis argument was further extended upon by Thrasymachus through incorporating the approach of injustice. Trasymachus tends to protect his previous stating injustice is stronger compared to justice.
Scrates disagrees with this concept of Thrasymachus. A per Socrates, i is injustice if a powerful city attacks a weaker region. O the other hand, Scrates even argues about strength acquired by a city would be on the basis of injustice or justice. Trasymachus replies by outlining injustice to be a source of such strength. Hwever, Scrates does not agree with this statement. Acording to Socrates, asuccessful group needs to work in collaboration with one another. Ijustice would divert mindset of group is the central component of success and this proves views of Thrasymachus to be totally contradictory.
C-operation within a group is adversely affected by the act of injustice. Wen there is lack of co-operation, n group member shall be aligned with a common goal or interest. Tis aspect is also true in individual context. I individuals are highly determined to adopt the path of injustice then it would restrict them to exhibit any productive or constructive work (Plato and Grube 134). This entire argument between Thrasymachus and Socrates inclined denoting injustice as an essential factor.
Tere was a shift of argument from justice to injustice. Trasymachus raised the argument of injustice in order to support his previous opinion regarding power and justice. Te approach of injustice is not applicable in most cases because it exploits thinking process of an individual or team member. O the contrary, pwer at times is strongly associated with injustice towards weaker section. I such scenario, agument of Thrasymachus proves to be correct because success in this case is achieved through performing towards others.
has stated an easy definition of justice in the first argument. Scrates. ..
Please type your essay title, choose your document type, enter your email and we send you essay samples